Hynes cleared for sudden-death Roosters clash after shock downgrade
September 8, 2025

Nicho Hynes is free to play on Saturday evening when the Cronulla Sharks face the Sydney Roosters in a knockout NRL semifinal, after the league downgraded Hynes’ hip-drop charge in a sensational backflip.
Incredibly, the NRL appears to have overruled the impending suspension — which the Sharks had planned to challenge — because Bulldogs winger Marcelo Montoya was less injured than first feared.
Win $500 Cash In Our Free Giveaway Here
The NRL read a letter sent by Bulldogs medical officer Dr Peter Lorentzos, which suggested “the injury is far less serious than initially expected” and went on to confirm Canterbury are now expecting Marcelo “will still be able to participate in finals… at some stage.” The injury, the letter added, appears to be a low-grade ankle ligament sprain, capsular strain, and joint effusion.
Hynes would have been banned for a single match (or two if found guilty), but is now free to play.
“The match review committee remains satisfied that there is sufficient evidence to justify a charge for the offence of dangerous contact against Nicho Hynes,” the NRL wrote in a surprise statement sent around to clubs on Monday.
Are you reading on our app? Download now for the best Sporting Base experience.
Win $500 Cash In Our Free Giveaway Here
“When initially ascribing a grading to that offence, the MRC considered the contents of a medical report provided by the injured player’s club, which offered preliminary details as to the nature and extent of the injury. Subsequently, the committee has received a further report which materially alters the nature and extent of the injury.
More NRL news
Red Hill loyalty: Payne Haas plans to stay in Brisbane
‘Had enough’: Hunt comes clean on Red V regrets
“Following due consideration… the match review committee has reviewed the charge against Hynes and, in accordance with the code, has forwarded the player an amended notice of charge for the offence of dangerous contact (Grade 1).”
At the end of all this, Hynes will simply be fined $1,000.
And, the Sharks star is now, of course, to be named on Tuesday to play the sudden-death final.
That match will be played at Shark Park on Saturday evening. The winner will face Brisbane or Canberra.
September 8, 2025
Smith agrees to join Knights, and not just as latest halves hope
Sandon Smith has signed a multi-year deal with the Newcastle Knights, in a move that will see the ex-Rooster play hooker for the Hunter club to allow Phoenix Crossland to swap to lock The Read MoreSeptember 8, 2025
NRL 2025 grades: Hapless Knights end with spoon
Halves issues, a lacklustre coach, and millions stuck on the bench saw the hapless Newcastle Knights capitulate to the club's fifth wooden spoon right on the last day of the 2025 NRL season with a Read MoreSeptember 7, 2025
Tell Us What You Think Below