James Tedesco has defended Latrell Mitchell’s enormous legal tackle on Toby Rodwell but questioned the South Sydney superstar’s decision to stand over the inexperienced Roosters halfback afterwards.
Mitchell produced one of the biggest hits of the season during the closing stages of South Sydney’s 50–20 victory at Allianz Stadium.
The Rabbitohs centre rushed out of the defensive line and drove his shoulder into Rodwell’s chest, sending the 20-year-old crashing onto his back.
Replays confirmed Mitchell had not made contact with Rodwell’s head, meaning the tackle was legal and no penalty was awarded.
However, Mitchell then stood over the dazed Roosters rookie and stared down at him as the South Sydney crowd celebrated.
Tedesco believes that reaction crossed a line.
“It was fair play from Trell, the hit he put on—but I’m not sure about standing over him after,” Tedesco told 9News Sydney.
“The poor kid is only 20 years old and played two games.”
Tedesco Refuses to Criticise the Tackle
Tedesco’s comments were not a complaint about the legality of Mitchell’s contact.
The Roosters captain immediately acknowledged that the tackle itself was fair and accepted it as part of the physical rivalry between the two clubs.
Rodwell had possession of the ball, Mitchell made contact below the neck and the young halfback was entitled to be tackled with force.
The NRL has spent years attempting to remove dangerous contact with the head without eliminating legitimate physicality from the sport.
Mitchell’s hit demonstrated the distinction.
It was confronting to watch and left Rodwell on the ground, but its severity did not make it illegal.
Tedesco said the young playmaker was “all right” after absorbing the contact, before directing his criticism towards Mitchell’s celebration.
When Nine reporter Danny Weidler described Mitchell’s behaviour as “fierce”, Tedesco appeared reluctant to intensify the controversy.
“Yeah, I don’t know,” he said with an awkward laugh.
“Fair play.”
The qualification matters.
Tedesco was disappointed by the taunt, but he was not calling for Mitchell to be suspended or punished retrospectively for the tackle.
Standing Over Rodwell Was Unnecessary
Mitchell is one of the NRL’s most physically intimidating players and had every right to celebrate an important defensive play against his former club.
However, the sight of an established representative star standing over a 20-year-old playing only his second NRL match was always likely to create criticism.
Rodwell had already been comprehensively beaten in the collision.
Mitchell did not need to add anything else.
The South Sydney centre may argue that the reaction was simply an emotional expression during the competition’s fiercest rivalry. He had just produced a perfectly timed hit in front of a sold-out stadium while helping the Rabbitohs embarrass the Roosters.
There is also no suggestion Mitchell verbally abused Rodwell or made further physical contact with him.
Yet Tedesco’s discomfort is understandable.
Celebrating with teammates or acknowledging the crowd would have preserved the aggression of the moment without directing it towards an inexperienced opponent lying on the ground.
The tackle was outstanding.
The intimidation afterwards was excessive.
Bennett and Murray Feared a Suspension
South Sydney initially feared Mitchell’s hit may have ended his finals campaign.
The angle shown live made the point of contact difficult to identify, forcing Rabbitohs supporters and officials to wait for the replay before celebrating.
Wayne Bennett admitted he experienced some concern.
Asked how he felt when replays confirmed the tackle was legal, the South Sydney coach replied: “Good.”
Asked whether he had been anxious before seeing the replay, Bennett said: “Maybe.”
Rabbitohs captain Cameron Murray was more direct, admitting he was “a bit nervous” about the possibility of high contact.
Losing Mitchell immediately before the finals would have been a devastating blow.
The 29-year-old only returned from a complicated nerve problem involving his back and calf against the Gold Coast in Round 26. He played limited minutes from the interchange before starting at centre and completing all 80 minutes against the Roosters.
Mitchell also scored a late try against his former club and appeared considerably more confident than he had during his cautious comeback appearance.
“He had that bit of a swagger that he has back,” Bennett said.
“He did some really good things. I was really pleased with the outcome.”
The tackle on Rodwell became the clearest demonstration that Mitchell was no longer protecting himself physically.
Roosters Will Remember the Moment
Tedesco did not play in the match after Trent Robinson rested nine established stars before the finals.
The Roosters also entered the contest without the injured Sam Walker, leaving Rodwell and Reece Foley to operate as an inexperienced halves combination.
That context made South Sydney’s 30-point victory less representative of the teams that could meet later in the finals.
Tedesco, Daly Cherry-Evans, Reece Robson, Billy Smith, Robert Toia, Mark Nawaqanitawase, Naufahu Whyte and Siua Wong are among the players expected to strengthen the Roosters’ side for September.
If the two clubs meet again, Mitchell’s treatment of Rodwell will not be forgotten.
The Roosters do not need to seek retaliation or manufacture an illegal response. However, Tedesco’s public comments ensure Mitchell’s actions will become another entry in the rivalry’s “Book of Feuds”.
That may have been exactly what Mitchell intended.
He spent the opening stages of his NRL career with the Roosters before moving to South Sydney, transforming himself into one of the central figures in the hostility between the foundation clubs.
Every confrontation involving him carries additional meaning.
Leniu Also Told to Control His Aggression
Tedesco also addressed Spencer Leniu’s volatile performance after the Roosters prop became involved in a confrontation with Keaon Koloamatangi.
Leniu reacted after being hit during a kick-off return and later continued exchanging words with the Rabbitohs forward.
The Roosters received a set restart before referee Adam Gee reversed the decision because Leniu continued the confrontation.
Tedesco praised the intensity Leniu brought to a young side but warned him not to become a liability during the finals.
“We told him to lead from the front, he was our most experienced forward out there,” Tedesco said.
“He plays with that passion, it was pretty exciting him going after it with all the young boys behind him.
“It’s just about knowing that line.”
The Roosters captain does not want Leniu to eliminate the aggression that makes him effective.
“He knows he can get carried away, but that’s the emotion and passion we want him to play with,” Tedesco said.
“That’s what brings the best out of him and we want him to do that, we want him to intimidate teams.”
The challenge for Leniu is almost identical to the debate surrounding Mitchell’s hit.
Controlled intimidation can decide finals.
Unnecessary provocation can decide them for the wrong reason.
Mitchell’s Hit Was Exactly What Rugby League Wants
Mitchell should not be criticised simply because Rodwell was young, inexperienced or badly shaken.
An NRL defender cannot pause before a tackle to calculate how many first-grade appearances the ball-carrier has made.
Rodwell stepped into the defensive line and Mitchell delivered a legal shot.
Removing that physical contest would diminish one of rugby league’s defining qualities.
Tedesco did not ask for that to happen.
His objection was limited to what occurred once the tackle had been completed.
That is the correct distinction.
Mitchell’s timing, commitment and technique should be celebrated. Standing over a defenceless rookie added little beyond creating another grievance between clubs that already possess enough reasons to dislike one another.
South Sydney will not be concerned.
Mitchell is healthy, avoided a penalty and appears to have rediscovered his physical confidence immediately before an elimination final.
The Roosters will view the same moment differently.
For them, the legal tackle ended when Rodwell hit the ground.
Everything Mitchell did afterwards has ensured the rivalry will continue long after he stood up.
MORE NRL NEWS: View Our NRL News Here
