Round 18 delivered more than just upsets and standout performances. It gave us a reality check for Kieran Foran’s Sea Eagles, another reminder of Valentine Holmes’ class, and a Tom Jenkins try-scoring surge that is quickly becoming one of the stories of the NRL season.
Manly’s 23-14 loss to Parramatta may prove to be one of the more damaging results of their season.
The Sea Eagles had been one of the feel-good stories of 2026 under Foran, climbing from early-season trouble into top-four contention after a dramatic mid-year turnaround. But Sunday’s defeat at CommBank Stadium exposed a worrying trend that will need to be fixed quickly if Manly is going to be taken seriously as a finals threat.
Foran did not hide from the issue after the game.
MORE NEWS: NRL: Thomas Jenkins Chasing 91-Year NRL Try-Scoring Record As Panthers Flyer Eyes History
The Sea Eagles coach criticised his side’s inability to control possession, pointing to errors and inconsistency as the major reasons they allowed the Eels to pull off an upset. Parramatta had already been beaten 33-18 by Manly earlier this season, but this time Jason Ryles’ side turned the tables with a far more disciplined performance.
Dylan Walker was outstanding for the Eels, producing one of the plays of the round with a brilliant flick pass to set up Kelma Tuilagi. Jonah Pezet also made a successful return to first grade, scoring a crucial try and kicking a late field goal to seal the result.
For Manly, the loss was made worse by their ongoing injury concerns.
The Sea Eagles were already missing key players, including Haumole Olakau’atu, while the new halves pairing of Joey Walsh and Jamal Fogarty was unable to consistently wrestle momentum back once Parramatta took control.
The defeat does not undo the work Foran has done since taking over, but it does change the conversation slightly. Manly has shown it can beat strong sides when it holds the ball and wins the middle. The concern now is whether the Sea Eagles can sustain that standard under pressure.
Elsewhere, Valentine Holmes produced one of his best performances since joining St George Illawarra.
The Dragons centre was instrumental in their 24-10 win over the Wests Tigers, scoring two tries, kicking four goals and making three line breaks in a performance that reminded everyone why he remains one of the most dangerous outside backs in the competition.
It was also a badly needed result for the Dragons.
Interim coach Dean Young has been trying to squeeze as much resilience as possible out of a side already planning for major roster changes, and Holmes’ performance was exactly the type of senior-player response St George Illawarra needed.
For the Tigers, the loss was a hammer blow to their fading finals hopes.
Benji Marshall’s side entered the match still within reach of the top eight, but their discipline, execution and defensive decision-making let them down badly. Api Koroisau’s suspected pectoral injury only added to the frustration on a night where the Tigers failed to make the most of a winnable game.
Then there is Tom Jenkins.
The Penrith winger continues to turn an excellent season into a historic one. His hat-trick against South Sydney took him to 25 tries for the year, equalling Rhys Wesser’s Panthers club record from 2003 and keeping him on track to chase Dave Brown’s long-standing single-season mark of 38 tries.
Jenkins has become one of the most reliable finishers in the NRL.
Playing outside Penrith’s slick attacking system certainly helps, but his positioning, strength and confidence have made him far more than just the beneficiary of good service. He is finishing chances at an elite rate and now has a genuine chance to create history if the Panthers keep rolling through the final stretch of the season.
Penrith’s 36-14 win over South Sydney also served as a strong response after a short form dip.
With Brian To’o and Dylan Edwards also standing tall during the Origin period, the Panthers once again reminded the competition that their depth and system remain the envy of the NRL.
Round 18 may not have completely changed the premiership picture, but it sharpened several storylines.
Manly still has the talent to be dangerous, but Foran needs his side to stop beating itself.
Holmes has given Dragons fans something to cheer about in a difficult season.
And Jenkins is no longer just chasing tries.
He is chasing history.
MORE NEWS: Parramatta Eels Circle Moses Leota as Panthers Face Massive Contract Call
