The New Zealand Warriors have climbed into third position and just dismantled the reigning competition leaders—but one leading rugby league journalist remains convinced their premiership dream will end in disappointment.
CODE Sports reporter Dean Ritchie has dismissed the Warriors’ title chances despite Andrew Webster’s side producing an emphatic 28-12 victory over Penrith at Go Media Stadium.
“It was a great win against the Panthers, but I don’t think the Warriors can win the comp,” Ritchie said on NRL 360.
“If they don’t make the top two, they can’t win away in Sydney. They can’t win through September unless they’ve got home finals.
“It will be Penrith versus Roosters, and the only way I will be proven wrong is after the preliminary finals.”
Ritchie’s comments were reported by Fox Sports.
Warriors deliver their strongest premiership statement
Writing off the Warriors immediately after their best victory of the season is a brave call.
Webster’s side did not scrape past an underperforming opponent or benefit from a controversial late decision. The Warriors dominated Penrith for most of the contest and built an 18-0 halftime advantage.
Erin Clark opened the scoring in the fourth minute before recalled halfback Luke Metcalf crossed seven minutes later.
Chanel Harris-Tavita extended the lead before halftime, while Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad and Metcalf completed the Warriors’ five-try performance.
Penrith scored twice through Nathan Cleary and Jaxen Edgar during the second half, but the Warriors regained control before Metcalf sealed the result in the 76th minute.
Metcalf finished with two tries and four conversions from five attempts.
The 16-point victory moved the Warriors within striking distance of Penrith and the Sydney Roosters at the top of the ladder.
Top-two finish could determine Warriors’ fate
Ritchie’s argument is based less on the Warriors’ talent and more on the pathway they may face during the finals.
Finishing inside the top two would likely give New Zealand home-ground advantage through the opening week of the finals and potentially the preliminary final.
The Warriors have consistently drawn enormous crowds at Go Media Stadium, where the atmosphere and travel demands create a genuine advantage.
Finishing third or fourth would still provide a double chance, but it could force Webster’s team to travel to Sydney during the opening week and again later in the series.
That possibility explains Ritchie’s refusal to rate the Warriors alongside Penrith and the Roosters.
However, a difficult finals route does not mean New Zealand “can’t” win the premiership. It means the Warriors’ margin for error would become considerably smaller.
The next few rounds will determine whether the Warriors can force their way into the top two and secure the home finals Ritchie believes they require.
Tallis rejects Warriors criticism
Queensland great Gorden Tallis took a dramatically different view of New Zealand’s title credentials.
“It’s about belief when you get to this time of the year, and to play the best side over the last 10 years in Penrith and beat them at their own game,” Tallis said.
“It wasn’t luck. It was a very hard-fought win.”
That assessment better reflects what happened in Auckland.
The Warriors matched Penrith through the middle, defended with aggression and converted their opportunities. They did not rely exclusively on broken play or individual brilliance.
Webster’s side has now won five of its past six matches, with its only defeat during that stretch coming against Canterbury.
Victories over Penrith, Gold Coast, St George Illawarra and the Wests Tigers have strengthened New Zealand’s position entering the final month of the regular season.
The Warriors have still never won an NRL premiership, but their Round 23 performance provided legitimate evidence that they can compete with the leading contenders.
Metcalf creates a selection dilemma
The bigger immediate issue for Webster is deciding whether Metcalf can possibly be removed from the No.7 jersey.
Metcalf had spent much of the season injured, outside the Warriors’ preferred halves combination or playing in reserve grade. He was recalled against Penrith only after Te Maire Martin suffered an injury during the club’s final training session.
Martin could reportedly miss up to a month.
His absence makes Webster’s short-term decision straightforward, but Metcalf’s performance may have changed the equation for the finals.
“Poor Te Maire Martin,” Braith Anasta said.
“He could be out for up to a month, and it probably makes Andrew Webster’s decision a lot easier this week with him being injured.
“He would have had a complete headache trying to make the call this week.”
Metcalf’s speed gave the Warriors an attacking dimension they have not consistently possessed through the middle of the season.
“I don’t think anyone expected him to be this good,” Anasta said.
“He hasn’t played for a long time in the top grade and he made an immediate impact.
“But he’s just come and put his hand up and almost said, ‘You have to pick me.’”
Warriors must ride the hot hand
Brent Read believes Webster must continue selecting Metcalf for as long as the halfback remains in form.
“You’ve got to go with the hot hand,” Read said.
“If he’s hot, he leads them to the top two going into the finals. You’ve got to go with the hot hand.”
Read suggested Martin’s expected recovery period may ultimately cost him an immediate return to the starting side.
“If it was a one-week injury, I think Te Maire Martin is back in,” he said.
“But because it’s four weeks and leading into the finals, and if Luke Metcalf gets the job done for four weeks, I don’t think you can change it.”
The Sporting Base has already argued that the Warriors must keep Metcalf at halfback following his Penrith masterclass.
His impending move to St George Illawarra should not influence Webster’s decision. The Warriors are attempting to win their first premiership now—not preparing their 2027 combination several months early.
Are the Warriors genuine contenders?
The doubts surrounding New Zealand are understandable.
The Warriors have never won a premiership, their finals campaign could require repeated travel to Australia and their halves combination remains unsettled with September approaching.
Penrith and the Roosters also possess substantially more recent finals experience.
But declaring that New Zealand “can’t win the comp” is too definitive for a side sitting third after beating the competition leaders by 16 points.
The Warriors possess a powerful forward pack led by James Fisher-Harris, Mitchell Barnett and Erin Clark. Wayde Egan provides creativity around the ruck, while Metcalf adds the speed capable of punishing defensive lines.
Their pathway becomes considerably harder if they miss the top two, but their premiership hopes remain genuine.
Ritchie may ultimately be proven right. Penrith and the Roosters deserve to be rated among the leading contenders.
The Warriors, however, have just given the competition a compelling reason to stop treating them as outsiders.
MORE NRL NEWS: View Our NRL News Here
