Two men have been charged over the alleged thefts of Australia’s most prestigious Cups, including Makybe Diva’s three, and the 1948 Caulfield Cup, Victoria Police said on Thursday. None of the trophies has been recovered and the investigation is continuing.
Police revealed that a fourth Melbourne Cup trophy was also allegedly stolen, on 12 November, four days before the Makybe Diva trophies were taken from Flemington. In a statement published by Mirage News, Victoria Police said detectives from the Melbourne and Moorabbin Crime Investigation units had charged the two men “following an extensive investigation”. Neither man is named here, and the allegations have not been tested in court.
Read more: Makybe Diva Melbourne Cups Stolen From Flemington Display
What police allege
“It is alleged three Melbourne Cup trophies were stolen from a cabinet, on Epsom Road, on 16 November about 6.30am,” police said. “It’s alleged a further Melbourne Cup trophy was also stolen on 12 November.”
Police also allege the Caulfield Cup was stolen after an offender entered premises on Station Street, Caulfield, on four occasions between 4 and 11 November. The cups have not been recovered at this stage, police said.
7NEWS reported that it is not yet known which year the fourth Melbourne Cup was won. The Sydney Morning Herald reported, citing an unnamed source, that the fourth cup was a replica on display at Flemington. Police have not confirmed that detail.
The charges and court appearances
Police said a 39-year-old Elsternwick man was arrested on 17 November and charged with burglary (two counts), theft (two counts) and possessing a drug of dependence. He was re-arrested on Tuesday and charged with further offences, including burglary, theft, handling stolen goods, dealing with property suspected of being proceeds of crime, obtaining financial advantage and obtaining property by deception. He appeared in Melbourne Magistrates’ Court on Thursday and was bailed until February, ABC News reported and the Herald.
A 36-year-old Mount Waverley man was arrested in Cheltenham on Thursday and charged with burglary (two counts), theft (two counts), committing an indictable offence while on bail, and dealing with property suspected of being proceeds of crime, according to police. The Herald reported that no bail application was made and he was remanded in custody. His lawyer told the court the prosecution case was “flimsy”, per ABC, while the prosecutor said the evidence included DNA, fingerprints and CCTV footage. Nine reported the same charges.
Both men are expected to face court again in February, ABC reported. Charges are allegations only and the accused are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Read more: 1948 Caulfield Cup Stolen From Caulfield Racecourse
Makybe Diva’s historic Cups
Makybe Diva won the Melbourne Cup in 2003, 2004 and 2005 and remains the only horse to have won the race three times. Her three trophies were part of a permanent display at Flemington, and are valued at an estimated $1 million each.
The 1948 Caulfield Cup, won by Red Fury, was bought at auction for $55,000 in March and was on loan to the Melbourne Racing Club, the club said on Wednesday.
For free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.
More News
