The Parramatta Eels have been there and thereabouts for some years now but none of their playmakers has had the dynamism to take them over the top—though they did come mighty close two years ago.
The biggest problems Parramatta face go hand-in-hand; one, their window seems to be sliding shut as players hit their ceilings and we see the best that Mitchell Moses, Clint Gutherson, and Dylan Brown can produce. Two, their roster is simply not improving (or it’s even regressing) while other’s strengthen.
That’s not to say they can’t have a good year—again, just look at 2022—but the strength and staying power has simply stayed in place and without Brown and Moses levelling up the Eels are coasting again.
Last year’s finish: Tenth, 12 wins and 12 losses
Last ten NRL campaigns: 10th, 4th (runners-up), 6th (semi), 3rd (semi), 5th (semi), spoon, 4th (semi), 14th, 12th, 10th
Predicted Round 1 lineup
Predicted Round 1 lineup
- Clint Gutherson
- Maika Sivo
- Will Penisini
- Daejarn Asi
- Bailey Simonsson
- Dylan Brown
- Mitchell Moses
- Junior Paulo
- Brendan Hands
- Reagan Campbell-Gillard
- Shaun Lane
- Bryce Cartwright
- J’maine Hopgood
- Ryan Matterson
- Joe Ofahengaue
- Kelma Tuilagi
- Wiremu Greig
Coach: Brad Arthur
Biggest losses: Nathan Brown Biggest gains: Morgan Harper
How 2024 is looking for Parramatta
For a team that needed more star signings injected into its ranks, having your biggest gain of the offseason be Morgan Harper is truly one of the most grim readings. The Eels definitely have the troops to challenge for finals and Dylan Brown is in the ascendancy, but reinforcements were definitely needed this year.
Instead, Brad Arthur comes in armed with the same team that backed up a 2022 grand final with an insipid 2023 campaign that may could argue ended when Harry Grant and the Melbourne Storm beat them in extra time in round one.
Gutherson and Moses have most definitely shown us their ceilings and while there’s engine room power like J’maine Hopgood, Reagan Campbell-Gillard, and Ryan Matterson, Parramatta needs a spark that they just simply can’t find right now. Perhaps that comes down to Brad Arthur’s reign and the oft-odd tactics he regularly dishes up, or maybe a top-class hooker could have been the answer. Either way, the Eels may have to watch their window slam shut this year.
Predicted 2024 finish: 10th
First five: Bulldogs (H), Panthers (A), Sea Eagles (H), Tigers (H), Raiders (A)
TopSport odds: Premiers $26, Make Top 4: $5.50, Make Final 8: $2, Miss The Top 8: $1.77
Pass mark: Prove the doubters wrong and hit another level.
