Cleary’s horrific prelim final injury not quite as bad as first feared

- Isaac McIntyre Cleary’s horrific prelim final injury not quite as bad as first feared Image
The Penrith Panthers are now hopeful that Nathan Cleary could be ready to return to play as soon as Round One, 2027, after confirming his brutal injury in the preliminary final isn’t quite as bad as first feared ⁠— though it will still take some serious recovery work.

The now-reigning Dally M Medallist has undergone two rounds of surgery since the horrific incident against the Newcastle Knights on September 27, with the majority of work going into what was widely reported as a double fracture in his tibia and fibula alongside a compound fracture.

Reports may not have been accurate, though, with the actual details as follows: Cleary first had work on a broken and dislocated ankle, and then went in for a second surgery for a fracture in his other foot.

“In terms of Nathan, the reporting kept saying it was a double fracture (but) it wasn’t a double fracture,” Penrith legend Greg Alexander suggested on radio this week.

“So, the two bones in your legs, fibula and tibia… he broke the fibula, the smaller bone. That wasn’t where the compound fracture came [from]. The pressure was on the tibia, which wasn’t broken, so it wasn’t a double fracture.”

More NRL news

Kiwis World Cup squad: Ponga, Gagai among New Zealand’s debutants

To the Tigers: Frizell is leaving the Knights after grand final loss

Famed physio Brien Seeney, who works in the NRL media, said that a tibia fracture often leads to “long, complicated recoveries,” whereas the fibula is far easier to manage.

Whether the Panthers actually decide to play Cleary in round one remains to be seen, of course.

He will definitely miss the 2026 World Cup, though; that starts next week.

Are you reading on our app? Download now for the best Sporting Base experience.


18+ Gamble Responsibly
CHANCES ARE YOU’RE ABOUT TO LOSE.

For free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au

Cta Bg Image

Want our tips and news Each Week?

We can email you our latest tips and news as they come in each week

Fill in the form & you will stop seeing this each time you view our insights & tips

Related Articles

Wangaratta Tips – Monday 16/11 Image Wangaratta Tips – Monday 16/11

Wangaratta hosts an eight-race program this Monday, with a Good 4 track and the rail out four metres setting the stage for a competitive afternoon of ...

1 day ago
Australia vs England 3rd ODI: Beardman Back for Hobart Decider Image Australia vs England 3rd ODI: Beardman Back for Hobart Decider

Mahli Beardman is set to return for Australia in the Australia vs England 3rd ODI at Bellerive Oval in Hobart on Wednesday 18 November, with the serie...

6 hours ago
Black Book: Horses You Must Follow From Ascot 14/11 Image Black Book: Horses You Must Follow From Ascot 14/11

The replays and stewards’ reports have been assessed from Saturday’s Ascot meeting. Our analyst has Black Booked two runners, including a ...

1 day ago
Header Logo
NRL Match Centre
Form guide